Gross’ Neighbors and Pawlikowski’s Ida
After reading Gross’ Neighbors and watching Pawlikowski’s Ida, I believe that the pieces of work compliment each other while sharing two different stories related to the horrific events that occurred...
View ArticleWeek 7
Gross’ Neighbors and Pawlikowski’s Ida both examine the legacy of the horrors of the Holocaust in Poland, albeit in different ways. In the film, Ida and her aunt look back twenty years after the...
View ArticleIda and Neighbors
By Madeline Kauffman I believe Ida and Neighbors to be excellent pieces of work that compliment each other quite well. Both focus on the horrific events that occurred during World War II, in which the...
View ArticleIda and Neighbors
I think that Ida and Neighbors, while complimentary, and certainly related, tell different stories, Ida providing a human aspect that Neighbors lacks. The film creates a face and a story for the...
View ArticleThe Importance of Neighbors and Ida
If studying the historical method has taught me anything, it is that there are multiple ways of telling a story. The way in which an event is presented depends on how the historian wishes to present...
View ArticleIda and Neighbors
After reading Neighbors and watching Ida, I feel like they generally serve as complimentary pieces. Both works shed light on the fact that Poles were just as guilty in the murder of local Jews as...
View ArticleIda and Neighbors
The question is a difficult one, as Ida and Neighbors can be viewed as either complements or separate entities, and both answers can be argued with validity. However, it was very interesting to view...
View ArticleIda and Neighbors
Ida and Neighbors are arguably both complimentary and stand alone pieces. As compliments of each other, Ida’s story continues the timeline of events initiated in the story told in Neighbors. While...
View ArticleIda’s Neighbors
Although Jan Gross’ Neighbors and Pawlikowski’s Ida both speak to similar events surrounding the destruction and murder of Jewish communities perpetrated by Christian Poles during WWII, I beleive that...
View ArticleWeek 8, October 21
Hello everyone, Just a note that, because we have an essay due this week, you will not have to write up a blog post. See you tomorrow! CJB
View Article
